Thread: Recommendations:: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by vasilis5755 Hello, Which game is better? Which one has better mechanics? War of the Ring(not the collector's edition) or Middle-Earth Quest ? Please advice.
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by Brother Jim They are completely different games; it depends on what kinds of games you enjoy. War of the Ring is a classic, thematic player vs. player game of strategy and tactics heavily informed...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by ekted Not even close.WotR is just about the perfect synthesis of euro, AT, and wargame sensibilities. Even without the theme, it's a fantastic game. It has real meat. A 9 for me.MEQ is typical FFG...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by Natus ekted wrote:Not even close.WotR is just about the perfect synthesis of euro, AT, and wargame sensibilities. Even without the theme, it's a fantastic game. It has real meat. A 9 for me.MEQ is...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by Dam the Man Owned both once upon a time, sold WotR after 21 plays, compared to MEQ, which got 60 plays in one third the time owned compared to WotR. No interest in re-acquiring WotR, but if I were...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by Sphere I bought WotR 1st edition and the Battles of the 3rd Age expansion. Then I bought WotR:CE. Played them, love them, would play today if I had time. And I'm seriously considering buying WotR...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by ekted I would urge the OP to consider the various replies by looking at our respective 9's and 10's. The OP's favorites line up a lot more with Rauli's than the rest of us.
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by Brother Jim ekted wrote:I would urge the OP to consider the various replies by looking at our respective 9's and 10's. The OP's favorites line up a lot more with Rauli's than the rest of...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by alex352 ekted wrote:I would urge the OP to consider the various replies by looking at our respective 9's and 10's. The OP's favorites line up a lot more with Rauli's than the rest of us.Excellent...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by Nap16 War of the Ring
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by bchlax944 MEQ is the more versatile game, and it isn't a war game. It certainly isn't an over exploitation of a license. It incorporates much more from the Middle-earth cannon (not just the...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by Sphere bchlax944 wrote:MEQ is the more versatile game, and it isn't a war game. It certainly isn't an over exploitation of a license. It incorporates much more from the Middle-earth cannon (not...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by Brother Jim Sphere wrote:bchlax944 wrote:MEQ is the more versatile game, and it isn't a war game. It certainly isn't an over exploitation of a license. It incorporates much more from the...
View ArticleReply: Recommendations:: Re: War of the ring VS Middle Earth Quest
by Eppic This depends ENTIRELY on player numbers Mostly 2? WOTR, no questionMore than 2? MEQ is a fabulous game for 3 and 4.
View Article
